№06 | The happiness curve has a missing question

9-minute read · Rather listen? Skip to the podcast below ↓

There’s a number that offers a peculiar kind of comfort: 47.

Have you ever looked at your life and wondered whether the best parts are still ahead of you?

It’s a strange question to find yourself asking, especially when so much of your life has already happened. Maybe it’s a birthday that catches you by surprise. You hear your age spoken out loud and, for a moment, it doesn’t quite sound like yours. There are decades behind you filled with experiences you couldn’t have imagined when you were younger, and years ahead that you have no way of predicting. And you find yourself wondering what those years might feel like.

A fascinating body of research suggests that happiness often dips around midlife before improving later. Economist David Blanchflower examined the relationship between age and happiness across 145 countries and found a widespread U-shaped pattern. Happiness tended to be higher in younger adulthood, decline toward the middle of life, and then begin climbing again. The lowest point varied, but it often appeared somewhere in the late forties. Hence the peculiar comfort of 47.

I find that strangely reassuring. There’s something appealing about the idea that at an age when we might assume the best years are already behind us, the average happiness line begins heading in the other direction. Of course, not everyone follows that curve. Researchers continue to debate how consistently it appears, and comparing people of different ages can’t tell us exactly what will happen as any one person grows older. Aging is not a guarantee that happiness is waiting around the corner.

But the pattern is intriguing because it challenges one of the stories we tell about getting older. Culturally, many of us have heard childhood is full of possibility. Our twenties are for finding ourselves. Our thirties and forties are for building careers, families, identities, and lives. After that, the cultural story becomes noticeably less enthusiastic. We hear more about slowing down, declining health, changing bodies, and the things we can no longer do quite the way we once did. Yet there’s research suggesting that some of our happiest years may still be ahead.

That made me curious. Not simply about whether happiness rises again, but about why life might begin to feel different, even better in later years. And eventually that led me to another question, one the happiness curve itself can’t answer: Who actually gets to experience the happier years on the other side of the curve?

What Time Changes Within Us

Psychologist Laura Carstensen and her colleagues followed adults’ daily emotional experiences over ten years. As people grew older, their emotional lives tended to become more stable, and the balance of their everyday feelings became more positive. But one finding caught my attention more than the others. Older adults were also more likely to experience positive and negative emotions at the same time.

I love that because it complicates our idea of what happiness is supposed to look like. We often imagine happiness as the absence of difficult feelings. The worries are resolved. The problems are handled. The disappointments have faded. Finally, we’re free to feel good. Perhaps emotional development doesn’t work quite that way.

You can be delighted that your child is building an independent life and feel the sadness of how quickly the years passed. You can be deeply grateful for a long relationship while acknowledging that loving another person has sometimes been terribly difficult. You can feel excited about the future and still grieve the things that will never happen. Growing older may not remove the contradictions. But it may change our capacity to hold them.

I find that possibility more reassuring than the idea that life will someday become uncomplicated. I’m not sure we need a future without difficult feelings in order to imagine a good one. But I like the thought that those difficult feelings might not have to occupy the whole room.

Carstensen’s work offers another clue. Her socioemotional selectivity theory suggests that when people perceive their future time as more limited, their priorities tend to shift toward emotionally meaningful goals and relationships. The experiments suggest that it’s not simply chronological age that matters. Our perception of how much time lies ahead can change what feels worth pursuing.

When we’re younger, the future can feel almost endless. There’s so much to learn, accomplish, discover, build, and become. A great deal of life is organized around expansion. Later, time may begin to carry a different meaning. Maybe part of the change is not that we stop caring about the future. It’s that we become more discerning about what deserves a place inside it.

And that makes me wonder whether some of what we call happiness later in life is not simply more pleasure. Maybe it is greater clarity about what matters.

What Might Emerge

We tend to notice the visible evidence of getting older first. The gray hair. The slower recovery. The reading glasses that seem to multiply around the house. Those changes are real. So are the losses that can accompany age. I don’t think we need to romanticize any of them.

But there are other changes that are harder to photograph. A growing ability to let two truths coexist. Less interest in impressing people who were never going to understand you anyway. A clearer sense of which arguments deserve your energy and which ones don’t. A different relationship with ambition. A deeper appreciation for ordinary time.

Age doesn’t guarantee wisdom, judgment, emotional steadiness, or perspective. We all know enough people to abandon that theory quickly. But neither does the loss of youth tell us everything about what a person may still be developing. Perhaps we’re so accustomed to thinking about aging as the gradual loss of what we were that we haven’t become nearly as curious about what might emerge in its place.

That question feels more interesting to me than whether we can somehow stay young. What might fifty make possible that thirty couldn’t? What might seventy teach us that forty had no way of knowing? What might become more precious precisely because time no longer feels unlimited?

There are things we can understand intellectually when we’re young and only embody that understanding after we’ve lived long enough to lose something, love something, change our minds, disappoint ourselves, surprise ourselves, and discover that an ending didn’t end nearly as much as we thought it would. Maybe later life is not simply the smaller life that remains after youth. Maybe something is still becoming.

The Conditions Matter

But there's an important problem with any story suggesting that people simply become happier as they age. People don’t age under equal conditions.

Researchers Andrew Steptoe and Paola Zaninotto studied adults ages 52 and older in England and found striking differences in aging across levels of wealth. People with fewer financial resources experienced worse outcomes across physical health, cognitive function, social participation, emotional well-being, and survival. Over eight years, 29.9 percent of those with the least amount of wealth died, compared to 15.7 percent of those who were among the wealthiest. Among those who survived and remained in the study, lower wealth was also associated with greater declines in enjoyment of life and more new cases of significant depressive symptoms.

The study doesn’t prove that wealth alone caused those differences. But it makes something important difficult to ignore. A person can become wiser without becoming financially secure. They can develop emotional resilience while living in circumstances that continue to demand extraordinary amounts from them. The happiness we experience as we move through life is shaped by both.

I’ve always found the idea that happiness is entirely an inside job a little too convenient. It places enormous responsibility on the individual while sometimes overlooking what surrounds them. Two people can turn seventy with decades of life behind them and still be entering very different futures. One may have financial stability, good health, meaningful relationships, and choices about how to spend the coming years. Another may be worried about medical bills, working longer than expected, caregiving for someone else, or wondering whether the money will last.

Both have accumulated experience, but experience does not erase circumstance. Getting older is not the same as becoming safer. And yet, this is where the research becomes more hopeful, because some of the conditions that make later life harder are not necessarily fixed.

Researchers at Johns Hopkins developed a program called CAPABLE for low-income older adults living with disability. Rather than asking people only to manage their health differently, the program brought an occupational therapist, a nurse, and a handyperson into their homes to help solve practical problems the participants themselves wanted to address. That might mean finding a safer way to bathe, adding a railing, repairing something in the home, managing pain, or making it easier to move through daily life independently.

In a randomized trial of 300 low-income older adults with disabilities, people who received CAPABLE showed greater improvements in their ability to manage basic daily activities than those in the comparison group. A separate evaluation of the program also found improvements in depressive symptoms. The studies don’t show that installing a grab bar makes someone happier. But they do show something important about the conditions in which well-being becomes more possible.

Sometimes helping someone feel better doesn’t begin by asking them to think differently. Sometimes it begins by making their life less difficult to navigate.

That distinction matters to the happiness curve. If well-being tends to improve later in life, the more interesting question is not simply whether age changes us emotionally. It’s who has enough support, security, health, connection, and freedom to experience the benefit of what those changes might offer.

Wealth can provide many of those things. But CAPABLE suggests that some of them don’t have to belong only to wealthy people. Practical support can be added. Environments can be changed. Obstacles can be removed. Someone’s daily life can become more manageable.

That doesn’t make happiness later in life a guarantee. But it does make it something more than luck.

The Years Still Ahead

This, to me, is part of what it means to be the CEO of your energy. The happiness curve may tell us something about what tends to happen as we age, but it doesn’t determine how any one of us will experience the years ahead. How we think. What we pay attention to. The meaning we make of our lives. And the conditions we create around ourselves. It all matters.

We can learn to hold difficult emotions differently. We can become more discerning about what deserves our time. We can invest in relationships that make life feel richer, ask for support before we’re desperate for it, and change parts of our environment that make everyday life harder than it needs to be.

Being the CEO of your energy means not leaving the quality of your experience entirely to chance. It means learning what helps you feel more alive, more supported, more connected, and creating more of those conditions in the life you’re experiencing now. I think that makes our later years worth being curious about.

What the Curve Can’t Tell Us

I began with the happiness curve because I liked the thought that life might begin moving upward again somewhere around age 47. There’s comfort in a graph that suggests the future might feel even better than today. But the more interesting possibility may be what the curve can’t tell us.

It can’t tell us who we’ll become. What we’ll stop caring about, what we’ll learn to hold more lightly, what relationships will deepen, what losses will impact us, or what ordinary parts of life will someday become precious. And it can’t tell us which conditions will make those possibilities easier to reach.

I believe the years ahead can hold surprising forms of meaning for all of us. And the happiness curve gives us something to be hopeful about. Maybe the question isn’t whether happiness improves at 47, 57, or 67. Maybe it’s about becoming increasingly capable of recognizing what makes a life worth living, and whether we have the conditions to experience the happier years on the other side of the curve.

Practice

Today, look for one small thing in your life that’s better now than it was a few years ago. It might be a relationship, where you live, a favorite piece of furniture, something that makes you smile, or something that makes everyday life a little easier, maybe even a little more fun.

These are the reminders that happiness can grow in ways we don’t always notice. Evidence that life really can get better with time.

From The Studio

🔆 Make Your Life Easier to Love | 3 Free Audios

A full life doesn’t always feel fulfilling. Take ten minutes to feel a little more alive in the life you already have.
​Listen to the free sampler →​

🔆 Podcast

A birthday that catches you by surprise, your age spoken out loud, and the reading glasses that seem to multiply around the house. This week’s podcast asks whether the best parts of life are still ahead, and what the happiness curve can’t tell us about the years to come. Listen on YouTube, Apple or Spotify.

​​​

FOLLOW THE ENERGY CEO

​​​​​